Love a diner brunch every now and then! Blue Bay serves up big portions and there is a wide variety of options to choose from. Service was friendly and coffee was constantly being refilled. Food was good and their purple cabbage cole slaw was so delicious! The space was clean and we were seated quickly for a Saturday morning.

Food is just diner food it's good they make it fresh we had a cheese burger deluxe a greek burger deluxe sweet potato fries old fashion French toast coffee and a chocolate layer cake it's no longer cheap to eat out so with $80 with the tip !!!

I haven't been to Blue Bay Diner since my highschool days, that is, until this past Saturday. I placed an order to pick up some matzah ball soup, a chicken caesar salad and a BLT with fries. As soon as I walked in, it was a total blast from the past. I could have sworn I recognize some of the staff from 15 years ago. When I got home, we had a feast. The chicken caesar salad was a huge portion and the matzah ball soups were quite tasty.Next time I will order a large soup as I would have liked a bit more broth. The sweet potato fries that came with my BLT didn't travel so well, so I might not order them again for takeout. The parking is a breeze, since the lot is huge and the handicap ramp entrance on the side is a plus. Overall, a classic staple that has been serving the community for decades. Wishing them continued success.

Huge portions! I mean really big! My first time at the BBD! Loved it! My buddy Bubba and his wife Rita are regulars here. They were slammed with people waiting but the very cool host and staff took care of everyone and had our party of 3 seated in 2 minutes. Our waitress was outstanding- sharp, quick and attentive. The coffee cups were refilled frequently as was the hot water for the tea. She brought out a bunch of napkins and a big serving dish with balsalmic dressing to go with the gargantuan side salad( photo). The eggs were hot. Everything tasted good. The coffee was good as well. My salad was fresh and crispy. The menu was pretty extensive with a special brunch menu accompanying the breakfast selections. Our new friends from Chicago who were sitting next to us also were pleasantly surprised with the sheer quantity when they got their orders. The burgers looked great and appetizing as did the bacon. The diner was packed and the staff adjusted very well to ensure a smooth flow of folks in and out of the dining areas. Definitely 5 stars for a fun and satisfying NY diner experience. Loads of parking in a big Food Emporium parking lot off the north service road of the Long Island Expressway.

Visiting the area. We were looking for nice, not fancy. Blue Bay served three courses for about $38-40/each plus credit card surcharge, which I didn't think was unreasonable for the excellent quality of the food (veal dish and chicken dish). The portions would have fed a family of two adults and two teenage boys. Felt a little bad we couldn't take some home. There were nice families with children around us. Nice family out-to-dinner place. We enjoyed seeing the kids enjoying a restaurant night.

It's a beautiful Saturday morning and I unfortunately had to get my car checked for an issue it is having. Lucky for me, the Blue Bay Diner was across the street from the auto shop (Barney's). Like many old-school diners, this place was open early (I walked in at about 7:30 am). They looked like they were pretty up and running and seated me right away. Not too long after someone came over to take my drink order, and the coffee and cranberry juice I got came right away. I decided to go big because I plan to be doing a lot of driving today and went with the French toast deluxe. The food came out right away! The portion sizes were very generous for the French toast, and everything else that came with it was pretty good. Great food, background music, service, and location. Can't ask for a better diner experience.